I note that that World War Two began seventy years ago today, well, according to the Polish government. Then again, the Czechs might date the conflict beginning earlier to March 1939 or even October 1938. The British, French and American governments ignored the Czechs, and dithered with the Poles. (Britain actually declared war on 3 September). On a more painful note, when did Hungary join in? Or 'Slovakia' for that matter? However, moving outside the region, one could point to the war rehearsal in Spain prior to that.
Be that as it may, what I found noteworthy was the current Polish government’s attempt to manage the international presentation of its past continued with a small ceremony in Westerplatte at CET 0445 today. President Kaczynski and Prime Minister Tusk joined veterans at the memorial to the Polish fallen on the peninsula.
In his address, Mr. Tusk said the lessons of history should not be forgotten. "We remember because we know well that he who forgets, or he who falsifies history, and has power or will assume power will bring unhappiness again like 70 years ago."
The Poles are famous for their sense of humour. I do wonder whether Mr. Tusk is famous for his sense of irony. I do not mean that it was ironic that Vladimir Putin of Russia, Angela Merkel of Germany and David Milliband, Britain’s Foreign Minister and also the son of Polish Jew joined Mr. Tusk in Warsaw later. Though of course, one could view that press conference as a study in the polyphonic politicization of memory. A study, which ignores start dates for example.
No, I mean Mr. Tusk’s comment about those who falsify history and the potential for unhappiness that it causes. This is ironic. I am reminded of the activities of Poland’s Institute for National Remembrance and the controversies it has initiated. Together with similar government-sponsored institutes in the Czech Republic, Slovakia and Hungary, it would be fair to state that much unhappiness has resulted. For these institutions are the whims of politicians seeking heroes in times when there were very few and where proper historical balance has been ignored in favour of headlines shaming once prominent public figures now deemed expendable.
The countries of central Europe face very similar challenges today to those faced in the late 1930s. What is called a ‘credit crunch’ and ‘recession’ today might very easily and more accurately be called a ‘depression’. Unemployment levels are rising, industrial output is falling and national debt is spiraling upwards. Russia seems to be sending out very mixed messages both politically and economically. Germany is the same though I thank Angela Merkel for not riding horses bare-chested.
Also, the governments of central Europe seem not to show any creativity when attempting to deal with disastrous economic data. Unfortunately, this is also true for the other European leaders in Warsaw this morning. Those leaders seem to be good at reminding us there is a war memorial in Westerplatte. They seem to be telling us not to forget history. The problem comes with what and whose version of history we should remember. It is basic economics that there is economic cycle and it is currently at a low point. It is common sense that governments cannot go on borrowing money. Further it is good business to focus on areas of agreement rather than a history of conflict.
Which brings me to Sophie Scholl in the afternoon of 22 February 1943 as she was led to a guillotine in Munich. She is reported to have said, “Die Sonne scheint noch”.
Photos show us that the sun was shining above Westeplatte at dawn this morning. History for the rest of 2009 and onwards has not been written yet.